Who will make the greater impact in MLS – Gerrard or Lampard?

Ahead of the much anticipated arrival of Premier League legends, Steven Gerrard and Frank Lampard to Major League Soccer, we look at who will have the greater impact.

LA Galaxy have had a slow start to the season and the pressure is mounting on Bruce Arena. Sitting seventh in the Western Conference is not where they would expect to be and if their poor run of form continues, more will be expected of Gerrard when he links up with the squad in July.

Embed from Getty Images

New York City FC have won just one game in their first season in MLS. They have shown promising signs but it is clear that they will need time to gain invaluable experience. Sitting ninth in the Eastern Conference is not ideal but Jason Kreis and NYCFC fans have to have realistic expectations of how their first season can unfold.

So how do the two compare in key areas in the Premier League this season?

Stats via Squawka

Apps Goals Assists Pass Accuracy Key Pass Shot Accuracy Tackles Won Average Mins/Game
Gerrard 28 8 1 85% 48 50% 35 77 mins
Lampard 31 5 1 85% 14 55% 15 30 mins

Lampard has played three more games than Gerrard but staggeringly averages just 30 minutes a game. The Manchester City midfielder has been used 22 times as a substitute, starting just nine. By stark contrast, Gerrard averages 77 minutes per game and has started 24 of his 28 appearances. Which implies that Gerrard will be the fitter of the two players when they join.

Embed from Getty Images

The two have had the same pass accuracy but Gerrard has made 34 more key passes (leading to a shot at goal) which is encouraging for the potential service he will supply to former teammate Robbie Keane. Lampard’s teammate to be, David Villa, has netted just two goals this season and is in desperate need of service.

These two have dominated the Premier League for years and there has been continual debate about who is the better player and that debate will now spread across the Atlantic. It is vital that both players hit the ground running and expectations of what they can bring are incredibly high.

Who will make the greater impact in MLS – Gerrard or Lampard??

Advertisements

Is Steven Gerrard a Premier League failure?

Steven Gerrard said an emotional goodbye to the Anfield faithful on Saturday as the Liverpool legend heads closer to his MLS move, but has his Premier League career been a failure?

The 34-year-old midfield powerhouse has been a Premier League runner-up three times in his Liverpool career and has spoke of his disappointment on not winning the title.

“I look back at it with pride,” he is quoted as saying by ESPNFC.co.uk. “I am really proud of what I have achieved here, all the trophies I have won and all the great memories I have had, but certainly not winning the Premier League is a dent in that.

Embed from Getty Images

“There is nothing I can do about it now but it is certainly a regret I will go away with. But I have to look at the big picture – [with] 708 appearances, I have achieved an awful lot more than I thought I would.”

Gerrard had the chance to join Chelsea under Jose Mourinho in 2005 where he could have been part of their Premier League winning side but his decision to stay with his boyhood club was admirable.

The soon-to-be LA Galaxy man can leave with his head held high, especially after that magical night in Istanbul where he led the charge for Liverpool’s comeback at 3-0 down.

Gerrard has scored a staggering 119 Premier League goals in 503 appearances, and given his input into every Liverpool side he has played in, it is possibly a club failure on not winning the league rather than an individual failure.

His biggest chance to win the title came last season when his painful slip against Chelsea eventually cost his side the trophy, but that should not overshadow his domestic career.

The former England captain is Liverpool’s top scorer this season and has once again led by example. His input is going to be hugely missed and his influence on expected captain-to-be, Jordan Henderson, is a great example of the role he plays in development.

Gerrard is undoubtedly a Liverpool and Premier League legend, but does never winning the title make his time in England a failure?

Former Liverpool goal-machine: ‘Gerrard is the best I’ve played with’

Former Liverpool striker Fernando Torres has claimed Steven Gerrard is the best player he has ever played with.

The statement from the 31-year-old Spaniard heaps an incredible amount of praise on Gerrard, as he was part of arguably one of the best World Cup and European Championship squads ever, playing with the likes of Xavi Hernandez and Andres Iniesta.

“I would chose him above all if I had to have him in my team, if I had him behind me,” Torres told Marca. “Steven Gerrard is the best player I have played with throughout my career, therefore my ideal player would be very like him.”

Torres has played with some of the highest quality teams and players in Europe but Gerrard is his number one.

“It is very difficult to choose because I have had the luck to play with a lot of great footballers. For me, the best is and has been Gerrard,”

Gerrard’s Liverpool career is almost over as he braces himself for the move to MLS with LA Galaxy this summer but he could have a fairytale ending with his boyhood club if Liverpool make it through their FA Cup semifinal this weekend.

The former England captain could lead his side out at Wembley in the final, which falls on the same day as his birthday, in his final appearance for the club before heading off to his exciting new challenge where Galaxy fans eagerly await his arrival.

Do you agree with Fernando Torres that Steven Gerrard is the best played he has played with?